The Stone Diaries

by Carol Shields | Literature & Fiction |
ISBN: 0670853097 Global Overview for this book
Registered by FuryIII on 12/4/2002
Buy from one of these Booksellers: | Amazon UK | Amazon CA | Amazon DE | Amazon FR | Amazon IT |
7 journalers for this copy...
Journal Entry 1 by FuryIII on Wednesday, December 04, 2002
I read this book a few years ago, and was not at all impressed. Although it won the Pulitzer in 1995, I find that particular prize to be fairly hit and miss (I loved Alison Lurie's Foreign Affairs and Michael Chabon's The Adventures of Kavalier and Clay, but others I haven't liked so well). For whatever reason, I decided to give the book a second airing, and just finished rereading it. Unfortunately, Daisy Goodwill Flett remains a pretty boring individual, and something of a cypher. But I realized that might be the point. We are, essentially, cyphers to those around us, and so frequently to ourselves, as well. And although the story still left me a bit cold, I really enjoyed Shields graceful prose, and the way in which she poked fun at biography as a medium of communication.

Journal Entry 2 by FuryIII on Saturday, February 15, 2003
Sent to Willemijn, a Carol Shields fan, in the Netherlands as a surprise addition to a parcel. I hope that she enjoys this volume and if she's already read it, has an opportunity to share it with someone else.

Journal Entry 3 by Willemijn from Deventer, Overijssel Netherlands on Saturday, February 22, 2003
What a lovely surprise to find another book in the parcel FuryIII sent to me! I really love Carol Shields, she knows that, so it's great even to touch&smell this penguin edition. I've read it ~ of course :-) ~ so it is available for further crossing. I'll find it a welcome new home.

Journal Entry 4 by Willemijn at SamSam eetcafé in Enschede, Overijssel Netherlands on Sunday, March 09, 2003
Released on Sunday, March 09, 2003 at SamSam eetcafe in Enschede, Overijssel Netherlands.

I will try to make a fellow bookcrosser enthousiastic for this book at a meeting we will have today.

Journal Entry 5 by jgralike from Almelo, Overijssel Netherlands on Sunday, March 09, 2003
willemijn radiantly recommended this book, how could I refuse it!

Journal Entry 6 by jgralike from Almelo, Overijssel Netherlands on Tuesday, April 15, 2003
beloofd aan biba89, dus ga hem nu snel lezen!

Journal Entry 7 by jgralike from Almelo, Overijssel Netherlands on Thursday, April 24, 2003
A diary, a biography, a novel? Telling the story of Daisy Stone, from what turns out to be her surprising birth untill after her silent dying, this book contains the stories of many people's lives. Seen through Daisy's eyes, mostly, accompanied by thoughts that dwindle on many things surrounding the people in her life, commenting on the way she is describing her own doings (and not-doings).
At first, I was taken by the words, touched.
Then I thought I would not finish the book, when the distraction of thoughts described took so many pages I could hardly say what the story was any more.
And then, suddenly, it had me again, and I let myself be taken on the waves of a life's story, and that of a family.

It is off to biba89, hope you will enjoy it!

Journal Entry 8 by jgralike at on Thursday, April 24, 2003
Released on Thursday, April 24, 2003 at to fellow bookcrosser in to fellow bookcrosser, sent it by mail Netherlands.

Journal Entry 9 by biba89 from Olst, Overijssel Netherlands on Friday, April 25, 2003
Dank aan jgralike, ik ga het lezen zodra ik het Ritsloze nummer, door Niana achtergelaten op mijn keukentafel, uit heb. Ik ben benieuwd, wordt dit een nieuwe Kingsolver voor mij?
And to Fury III, in English: I'll let you know what I found in these pages as soon as I have finished them.

Journal Entry 10 by biba89 from Olst, Overijssel Netherlands on Monday, May 12, 2003
This book looks like a biography. And, like the former bookcrossers, I do not know either who Daisy Stone is, really. Or what moves her. The book itself though is fascinating enough to want to keep reading. The strangest thing I have encountered in the book: real pictures of real people as characters from the story. Playing with the concept of biography? I found the concept quite chilling. Pondering about it I thought they were no different from actors in a film, pretending to be someone else. But to me it felt as if the writer borrowed the existence of these anonymus people for her own good.
Nevertheless, I enjoyed this book.

Release planned for Tuesday, May 13, 2003 at to fellow BookCrosser in Deventer, Overijssel Netherlands.

In de rode brievenbus, op weg naar nrrdgrrl

Journal Entry 12 by nrrdgrrl from Johannesburg - Fourways, Gauteng South Africa on Wednesday, May 21, 2003
funny: biba89 returned an envelope that previously carried a smelly dog treat. now it comes back containing the stone diaries and it smells of flowers!
that gives me visions of biba sanitizing the entire house after the dog book experience...
apparently there are no hard feelings because the book travelled in company of a beautiful red jasper gem stone. thank you biba! much appreciated!

about the book, i'm very curious what it will be like. especially after the mixed impressions of other people.
this book hasn't been spoken for, so it won't be on the very top of my tbr list - though i do have someone in mind who might enjoy it. still, if you would like to be next, feel free to let me know.

Journal Entry 13 by nrrdgrrl from Johannesburg - Fourways, Gauteng South Africa on Thursday, July 17, 2003
sad news, alas, also has a place in the history of a book.
today, carol shields passed away after loosing her fight with breast cancer.

Journal Entry 14 by nrrdgrrl from Johannesburg - Fourways, Gauteng South Africa on Sunday, August 17, 2003
this book has been promised to jolanda. i tried to put up a non-american "rest of the world" bookray to commemorate the author's death but got only one reply. luckily thnxandyc's simultanuous american bookring received a bit more enthusiasm.
as a result, it's totally up to jolanda what the future of this book looks like.

since the beginning of the month i've been trying hard to finish the book. but somehow that's not so easy. will report back when i have more time.

Journal Entry 15 by nrrdgrrl from Johannesburg - Fourways, Gauteng South Africa on Monday, August 25, 2003
it took me a lot of effort to get a grip on this book. i'm very fond of the idea, you see, of creating a life story and having it commented by everyone who could have played a role. the photos in the book are the same thought as ottawabill's project: found photos receive a story to go with them. an old technique, but fun to do!

what tired me much was shields' style. the story kept going in endless circles. it was nice to get more depth every time, but to keep going required an interest in the protagonist's life that reached way beyond my stamina. kaleidoscopes are more fascinating to the patient, i guess.

in the end i tried grazing the stories and that didn't work either. so even though i gather i've read most of the book or maybe even the entire book, i'm not quite sure.

Released on Tuesday, August 26, 2003 at controlled release in hilversum, noord-holland Netherlands.

off daisy goes, to jolanda, in a true bx envelope. i think it's the fifth book that travels in this wrapping!

Journal Entry 17 by Jolanda from Rotterdam, Zuid-Holland Netherlands on Wednesday, August 27, 2003
I've received the book today. As there are several books waiting to be read, it can take a while before I start this one.

Journal Entry 18 by Jolanda from Rotterdam, Zuid-Holland Netherlands on Sunday, January 09, 2005
I finally read this book. I'm not sure what to think of it though. It took me quite some time to get myself in the story and half way the book I started to enjoy it. However towards the end I got bored again. OVerall a nice book to read but not a book I will read for a second time.

Journal Entry 19 by Jolanda at the mail in Rotterdam, a fellow bookcrosser -- Controlled Releases on Thursday, April 07, 2005

Released 14 yrs ago (4/7/2005 UTC) at the mail in Rotterdam, a fellow bookcrosser -- Controlled Releases



On it's way to another bookcrosser

Journal Entry 20 by Winterson from Peacehaven, East Sussex United Kingdom on Wednesday, April 13, 2005
Middling reviews for this one, but I love Carol Shields, so I'm keen to give it a go. Thanks Jolanda :)

Are you sure you want to delete this item? It cannot be undone.