Deception Point

by Dan Brown | Mystery & Thrillers |
ISBN: 0671027387 Global Overview for this book
Registered by suedo of Redditch, Worcestershire United Kingdom on 4/12/2006
Buy from one of these Booksellers:
Amazon.com | Amazon UK | Amazon CA | Amazon DE | Amazon FR | Amazon IT | Bol.com
This book is in the wild! This Book is Currently in the Wild!
6 journalers for this copy...
Journal Entry 1 by suedo from Redditch, Worcestershire United Kingdom on Wednesday, April 12, 2006
Pre-numbered label used for registration.
had it a while, got it through trade, it's on my partners TBR stack

Journal Entry 2 by wingAnonymousFinderwing on Sunday, April 16, 2006
I enjoyed Angels & Demons and The DaVinci Code (after all, I'm usually quite good at suspending disbelief), but I've developed a problem with Dan Brown. He advocates Bad Science in the worst possible way.

I had to give up on Digital Fortress very early on, because he either had not done his research into cryptography, or had done his research but failed to understand it. Either way, he was going into a lot of detail that was utter nonsense.

This one I borrowed from my partner. Deception Point starts out OK, the prose is perfectly readable, and there is a character about which one finds oneself caring. BUT, then the Bad Science kicks in and this has put me right off.

First is his maths. There is an object (remotely detected by its unusually high density, if you can believe that) described as being 10 ft in diameter and weighing "over 8 tons", although later references take the 8 ton figure as definitive. If it is even aproximately spherical, its volume is around 14 cubic metres. Ergo, if it is the same density as water it will weigh 14 tonnes. His phrasing opens the possibility that it is actually less dense than water. There is no excuse for getting this wrong; the formula for the volume of a sphere is about as simple as they get, and is readily available.

Second, he has an "expert" on meteorites describing the heat of entry into the Earth's atmosphere. And this character states that the heating is due to friction. Oh, dear. This is demonstrating very poor research on the author's part. Every expert on meteorites is well aware that the heating is due to compression of the air in front of the object, with perhaps a 1% contribution from friction.

Third, there is a discussion of the possibility of extraterrestrial life, in which he states that it is well known that ET life is most likely to be arthropod (insects, spiders, scorpions etc.), because they make up 95% of species on Earth and 40% of the biomass. Well, maybe that's true of the animal kingdom, but, hello?, what about the plants, fungi, bacteria, cyanobacteria, protista and archaea? At one point, he even mentions meteorite ALH84001, the one in which NASA claimed to find fossil microbes back in '96. In fact, it has been known for a long time (perhaps 20-30 years) that ET life is most likely to be microbial (bacteria or something rather like them), which is why NASA made such a fuss over ALH84001. Again, this demonstrates sloppy or non-existent research. It is not difficult to find rational speculation about the possible form of extraterrestrial life.

Fourth, he states that arthropods are the hardiest of organisms. Well, some of them are very hardy (expecially tardigrades, aka water bears), but there is a class of bacteria on Earth referred to as "extremophiles", because they thrive in extreme conditions (e.g. high temperature, high acidity, high alkilinity). Extremophiles beat any arthropod hands down at tolerating extreme conditions, hence the name (a kind of English-Greek compound word indicating affinity for extreme conditions). This error could be artistic licence taken to set up a plot device, but I won't say why (to avoid spoilers). No matter why, it is still wrong, and it still smacks of poor research.

Fifth (yes, it goes on!), there is one point where they are lifting this object (specifically described as "stony") through many feet of ice. They heat it with a laser so it will melt the ice as they haul it upwards. Again, oh, dear. Stone is a very poor conductor of heat (as anyone who has read "Pigeon Post" by Arthur Ransome will know). If you point a powerful laser at a large stone, you will crack the stone. You will certainly not end up heating the entire stone. Again, this is either poor research on the author's part or a failure to take the trouble to understand what he wants to describe.

I have reached page 133 out of 557, and decided to give up on this.

In conclusion, I am inclined to agree with Stephen Fry's assessment of Dan Brown novels. Look at the personal quotes in Stephen Fry's entry on the imdb:
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000410/bio

CAUGHT IN SPENNYMOOR CO. DURHAM UK

Journal Entry 3 by suedo from Redditch, Worcestershire United Kingdom on Sunday, April 16, 2006
Well, I find it easier to suspend reality than my partner, but I also have given up on this author.
This will be up for trade at www.sf-books.com
Sending as a RABCK to celebrate my new job

Journal Entry 4 by rosiewhippet from Fenstanton, Cambridgeshire United Kingdom on Tuesday, May 09, 2006
Received safely thanks, funnily enough I am just coming to the end of Digital Fortress also by Dan Brown, guess I'll start this one next then!!

Thanks,
Rosiewhippet.

Journal Entry 5 by rosiewhippet from Fenstanton, Cambridgeshire United Kingdom on Monday, October 30, 2006
Finally got round to reading this one. It was the last Dan Brown book I had to read and was really looking forward to it...as I really enjoyed his other three. However I was a bit disappointed, I didn't think it was up to his usual standard of writing. Nevertheless I enjoyed it and in a few places was unsure of what was going to happen.

Thanks to suedo for sending me this RABCK. And to follow suit I am sending this as a surprise RABCK to Luckeydipper who has it on her wishlist.

I will be forwarding it on as part of 'The 2006 Keep Them Moving Challenge'

Rosiewhippet. x


Journal Entry 6 by rosiewhippet at RABCK to fellow BCer! in Coolangatta, Queensland Australia on Monday, October 30, 2006

Released 12 yrs ago (10/30/2006 UTC) at RABCK to fellow BCer! in Coolangatta, Queensland Australia

WILD RELEASE NOTES:

RELEASE NOTES:

Luckydipper - Surprise!! Hope you like the RABCK. I saw it on your Wishlist!!

Please visit my Guestmap and stick a pin on it!

Rosiewhippet. x

Journal Entry 7 by luckydipper from Coolangatta, Queensland Australia on Friday, November 03, 2006
Wow that was fast, either you journaled awhile after sending or it really does have wings and flew directly to me :)
Thank you so much for sending me a surprise book from my wishlist, you have really made my day.

Ps. Thanks heaps for the postcard, it has filled a special place in my album.

Journal Entry 8 by luckydipper from Coolangatta, Queensland Australia on Thursday, March 29, 2007
I finally got around to finishing this book, not as good as the the DaVinci Code but ok, I do struggle to read books that are not chick lit or womens fiction, but I want to read other types so I did, Good; but I would not want to read it again, thanks again Rosiewhippet for the opportunity to read this book and for posting it to me from across the big blue sea :)

update: I have just checked with rabck.com and found another BCer who would like to read this book, so it is being mailed off with another Dan Brown book I have at the moment.

Released 12 yrs ago (5/31/2007 UTC) at Surprise RABCK using Cliff Wishes in Gold Coast, Queensland Australia

WILD RELEASE NOTES:

RELEASE NOTES:

'Surprise' I saw on cliff wishes that you would like to read this book, I then confirmed your address on both rabck.com and your profile page ...... and tadaah here tis...

Happy Bookcrossing gingechick!

Journal Entry 10 by lostbookisland on Wednesday, October 24, 2007
This book has washed ashore at the Lost Book Island after not being heard from for many months. This new arrival will be shown to a room and be allowed a bit of rest before being introduced to the many fun things to do here at the island.

All around there are books sipping cool drinks under shady palms while other books participate in a wide variety of beach sports. There is plenty of sand, surf and sun here for all of the lost and wayward books to enjoy.

It is hoped that very soon a new journal entry will come to rescue this book from the island and send it back out into the BookCrossing world so that it may continue on its journey. It is hoped that the new journal entry will tell all the interested parties where this book has been this long time and where it will be traveling to next.

Journal Entry 11 by gingechick from Brisbane, Queensland Australia on Friday, December 14, 2007
This was sent to me as a RABCK earlier this year. I have only just realised i have journalled it. ...sorry Lucky Dipper!
I am going to start on reading this on the weekend!

Released 11 yrs ago (5/19/2008 UTC) at A Bus Stop on Anzac Avenue in Kallangur, Queensland Australia

WILD RELEASE NOTES:

RELEASE NOTES:

Enjoy!!

Are you sure you want to delete this item? It cannot be undone.