Catilina's Riddle (Second Copy)

by Steven Saylor | Literature & Fiction |
ISBN: 1845292413 Global Overview for this book
Registered by Mastulela of Nuneaton, Warwickshire United Kingdom on 2/16/2006
Buy from one of these Booksellers: | Amazon UK | Amazon CA | Amazon DE | Amazon FR | Amazon IT |
8 journalers for this copy...
Journal Entry 1 by Mastulela from Nuneaton, Warwickshire United Kingdom on Thursday, February 16, 2006
The first copy was defective, so this is replacing it.

Book Ray


Third in Saylor's Roma sub Rosa series, it takes Gordianus the finder into the Etruscan countryside. While there Cicero asks him to keep an eye on the radical populist senator, Catilina, and is drawn into a web of deceit, intrigue and murder.

This is the thickest (in size - 700 pages) of the series!

Journal Entry 2 by Mastulela from Nuneaton, Warwickshire United Kingdom on Friday, February 17, 2006
Postal release to Loopy1 today.

Journal Entry 3 by loopy1 from Herne Bay, Kent United Kingdom on Saturday, February 18, 2006
This enormous tome turned up on my doorstep today. Thanks, I'm looking forward to reading it. I've really enjoyed all the Gordianus books so far.

Journal Entry 4 by loopy1 from Herne Bay, Kent United Kingdom on Saturday, April 22, 2006
Just wanted to say that I'm still reading this one! It's a big book, and quite heavy going so far as it's much more political than the others.

But I'm persevering, and the train journey to the London meetup today should help move things along :-)

Journal Entry 5 by loopy1 from Herne Bay, Kent United Kingdom on Monday, May 01, 2006
I finally managed to finish this book today. I found it harder going than the other Gordianus books, less about mystery and more about politics. It did get going more towards the end though, and was worth reading because of the historical background. It also portrayed clearly the political machinations behind assassinations of character and of people.
I'll be passing it on once I have an address. Thanks for sharing!

Journal Entry 6 by loopy1 from Herne Bay, Kent United Kingdom on Tuesday, May 02, 2006
Off to Rillaith today.

Journal Entry 7 by Rillaith from Wokingham, Berkshire United Kingdom on Thursday, May 04, 2006
Arrived safe and sound today, but it's a couple down the pile due to a bit of a backlog at the moment. Been looking forward to more of these!

Journal Entry 8 by Rillaith from Wokingham, Berkshire United Kingdom on Wednesday, June 21, 2006
I've loved reading this one, and despite its daunting size it's gone quite quickly. It would have been faster if I hadn't left it behind at two different friends' houses mid-way-through, though!

Will ahve this finished by the end of the week, so will be journeying on to YowlYY very soon. Thanks for letting me read it!

Journal Entry 9 by YowlYY on Saturday, July 01, 2006
Thanks to Rillaith for bringing this to the Unconvention, where it was *very safely* handed over...yes, it took me 10 minutes to get it out of the jiffy bag, thanks to the cellotape :)

I will be starting this tomorrow, and it will be my excuse for not doing any housework during the hot hours ;)

Journal Entry 10 by YowlYY on Thursday, September 14, 2006
I did not start this one in July as promised... it took me several weeks before I could tackle the 600+ pages, but once started, I was hooked just like with the previous novels. I met a Gordianus who is several years older than in the last adventure, a more cautious side is shown, maybe also due to the fact that he founds himself with a real family and a daughter, and the new scenary of the farm has been a pleasant change from the city background. I agree that this one is more political, but I found it extremely interesting and helped me remembering some of the literature lessons I had when I was 16...the so called "Catilinarie", written by Cicero, do not have the same taste now, after reading Saylor's novel! Now I look forward to the next episode...

I have been in contact with Mastulela to have this book travel a bit more, and she agreed that since rainbow3 has been so far so enthusiastic about Gordianus' adventures, it is only fair to have it moving to Edinburgh fairly soon.

Thanks again for a great read!

Update 16.10.06: the book is leaving today to Edinburgh...happy reading!

Journal Entry 11 by rainbow3 from Edinburgh, Scotland United Kingdom on Thursday, November 30, 2006
What a treat I am chortling with gleeful anticipation. I plucked it with delight from the hands of Ken the post man as I left the flat in a tearing hurry on Tuesday (17th October) and was unable to open it till that evening. So now a fast journal to let you know it has arrived! I am thrilled to have it and am delighted you were kind enough YowlYY to offer it to me. Great big, huge thank you’s!

UPDATE: 30 Nov 06, St Andrews Night ;-) I wrote that journal entry but have been unable to add it to the site till now, SO HUGE APOLOGOES FOR THIS LATE, LATE, LATE ENTRY.

Now the next embarrassment ~ is that I have actually read it but forgotten to update my flash drive with my review, so cannot add it now. It will be added though, I promise. I can easily tell you all that I really enjoyed this and yes a whole doze of historical stuff that i sped through I'll admit. However the weight of that element gave me great confidence in recommending this series to a now-retired classicist. He sounded very interested and in time I expect I shall hear more. Needless to say he's off to hunt in his local library as he wants to start at the beginning of the series.

PS ~ Any thoughts anyone on whom to send this to next???

Journal Entry 12 by rainbow3 at Post Office, Leith Walk in Leith, Scotland United Kingdom on Saturday, March 03, 2007

Released 12 yrs ago (3/5/2007 UTC) at Post Office, Leith Walk in Leith, Scotland United Kingdom



utterly thrilled to have been contacted by kizmiaz who is bouncing and keen to have this. Yahoo!!!
I am planning posting this off in the coming week, whenever i receive kizmiaz's address. Very happy reading to you kizmiaz.

UPDATE: Wed 14th March book posted yesterday, by surface post.

Journal Entry 13 by kizmiaz from Belém , Lisboa (cidade) Portugal on Monday, April 02, 2007
Just got it, thank you very much rainbow3. I loved the Scotich brochures too, yours is one of the countries that I'd really love to visit. Who knows maybe one of these days... we'll see, anyway if I do get there I'll most certainly get in touch with you.
Thanks again for sharing the book.

Journal Entry 14 by kizmiaz from Belém , Lisboa (cidade) Portugal on Monday, September 29, 2008
It took me a while to get to it but I really enjoyed this book; it’s actually the best book I’ve read by Steven Saylor.
I’ve read Roman Blood and Arms of Nemesis and enjoyed the second more than the first mainly because I’m not much of a “whodunnit” books fan but especially because Gordianus becomes more of a character in the second book. But this one takes the cake, this is way more than a whodunit, this is an historical novel with a bit of mystery but dealing mainly with the political world at the end of the Roman republic and the mischief of professional politicians, this rang a few loud bells (just check Cicero’s arguments against Catilina and his use of rumours and then think George W. Bush and the rumours about chemical weapons in Iraq in 2002).
Catilina is a riddle all by himself mainly because of the scarce information we have on him (only his enemies wrote about him so it’s like getting the story on Saddam as written only by Bush Jr.) and the author makes good choices in trying to show the readers the other side of the story and its possible ramifications.
With this book it gets very easy to see how the Roman republic couldn’t fail to collapse in a few years.

Journal Entry 15 by kizmiaz from Belém , Lisboa (cidade) Portugal on Monday, September 29, 2008
Reserved for yorkshire-lass

Journal Entry 16 by kizmiaz at Fellow bookcrosser, A Book Swap! -- Controlled Releases on Monday, October 06, 2008

Released 11 yrs ago (10/1/2008 UTC) at Fellow bookcrosser, A Book Swap! -- Controlled Releases



Hope you enjoy it for yorkshire-lass.

Journal Entry 17 by wingyorkshire-lasswing from Maidstone, Kent United Kingdom on Monday, October 06, 2008
The book arrived safely today,thank you kizmiaz. I'm looking forward to reading this but as Mt TBR is massive at the monent it may take me a while to get to it.

Journal Entry 18 by wingyorkshire-lasswing from Maidstone, Kent United Kingdom on Sunday, March 08, 2009
Got to it at last! I must admit that the size of this was daunting to begin with, but once I'd started it I got so into it that it only took about four days to read it.It was more political than the previous books but because it's so well written and not at all "dry" I found it fascinating.
Thanks so much for sending it to me kizmiaz,and I'm looking forward to the next one!

Journal Entry 19 by wingyorkshire-lasswing at By Mail, A RABCK -- Controlled Releases on Monday, February 22, 2010

Released 9 yrs ago (2/23/2010 UTC) at By Mail, A RABCK -- Controlled Releases



This is now on its way to conto in Portugal, who is another Gordianus fan. Hope you enjoy it!

Journal Entry 20 by conto from Lisboa (city), Lisboa (distrito) Portugal on Friday, February 26, 2010

Got it, thank you very, very much yorkshire-lass!
I can't wait to get started on this so highly recommended volume of the series. Will come here afterwards to share my thoughts.

Journal Entry 21 by conto from Lisboa (city), Lisboa (distrito) Portugal on Saturday, March 13, 2010
Wow, what a brilliant piece of (big) work, Saylor gives us with this book!

I loved every minute I spent reading it and I was in awe with the almost pictorical details on the political and electoral systems in the Roman Republic.

I also think that Saylor did a wonderful job with the fictioned descriptions of the Catilinian affair (curiously, today "catilinaria" in italian means something like 'bitter invective') opening some doors but not choosing sides in a mystery that will forever be.

Now I'm a bit afraid of getting on with the rest of the series for I guess I'll be looking for something more of this in the other books, which I won't probably find.

Thank you once more yorkshire-lass, for the opportunity to read this book. I will now try to convince my brother to read this one, because I think he'd like it.

Are you sure you want to delete this item? It cannot be undone.