Pinkerton's Sister
Registered by zz-neena of Hopewell Junction, New York USA on 5/1/2005
This Book is Currently in the Wild!
1 journaler for this copy...
will journal when read
Purchased with great glee, and thrown on the *available* pile:
Have you ever happened upon a book that had all the elements you would choose if you were looking for the *ideal* book for you to read, only to find nothing but a profound disappointment- all the sharper for the anticipation once felt.
Such was my experience with Pinkerton's Sister. This book had everything. It is set in Victorian>Edwardian NY (my very favorite time period), and it has a heroine drunk on literature. References to dozens of notable books enhance every page.
So what went wrong?
The author forgot just one thing- a plot.
Stream of consciousness is all very well, but it's been done. I already learned to hate Virginia Woolfe and James Joyce for this- I thought we were through with it.
I'm so sorry to give this book such a low grade, but, hey, it could have been just great and it isn't.
Have you ever happened upon a book that had all the elements you would choose if you were looking for the *ideal* book for you to read, only to find nothing but a profound disappointment- all the sharper for the anticipation once felt.
Such was my experience with Pinkerton's Sister. This book had everything. It is set in Victorian>Edwardian NY (my very favorite time period), and it has a heroine drunk on literature. References to dozens of notable books enhance every page.
So what went wrong?
The author forgot just one thing- a plot.
Stream of consciousness is all very well, but it's been done. I already learned to hate Virginia Woolfe and James Joyce for this- I thought we were through with it.
I'm so sorry to give this book such a low grade, but, hey, it could have been just great and it isn't.
Journal Entry 3 by zz-neena at East Fishkill library in Hopewell Junction, New York USA on Saturday, October 18, 2008
Released 15 yrs ago (10/18/2008 UTC) at East Fishkill library in Hopewell Junction, New York USA
WILD RELEASE NOTES:
WILD RELEASE NOTES:
in front
in front