This is no light read. If you like to read books that address topics like abortion, lesbian relationships, incest,and violence then this is the book for you. The characters are very well done. All of the characters are interesting and you can't help but care what happens to each of them. The graphic medical details I could have done without but like another reviewer said, this book will stay with you. It will also make you think.
Arrived today...THANK YOU, perryfran! I should start it this weekend.
1/15/09 -- I must say that this book was long. However, I really enjoyed this book. The characters are very vivid and complex. This is the first novel I've read by John Irving and it was brilliantly written. After the first few chapters I found myself looking at the copyright date. His style was definitely period specific and I thought for sure that it was written in the 50's or 60's.
Thank you again, perryfran, for including me.
Journal Entry 5 by Lumbermoose at BOOKRING, -- By post or by hand/ in person -- USA on Thursday, January 15, 2009
Released 3 yrs ago (1/16/2009 UTC) at BOOKRING, -- By post or by hand/ in person -- USA
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Sending on to hopi100. Thank you perryfran for getting a replacement book for this ring!
Oh, wow, what an intense book! But I would expect nothing less from John Irving. This was such a good book -- as I said, it was intense, but that made it very difficult to put down and drew me into the characters with great ferocity!
Thanks so much, Perryfran, for including me in this ring! Afraberg has asked to be skipped, so I will be mailing this off to Ekranda soon -- most likely over the weekend.
Sorry for the slight delay in a journal entry. Received the book yesterday during last minute editing of one of my assignments....(which i handed in this afternoon!!). I've got a ray and a spiral to read before this one but hope to read it soon. Thank you very much for sharing...i've seen the film and really enjoyed that so i'm hoping the book will be even better!
* Update: 8 June: I'm about half way through this book at the moment. Been so busy recently that i haven't had much time to sit down and read. Hope to finish it soon and send it on. Will keep you updated!!!
I thought this was a fantastic read! It was rather heavily themed and very deep topics were covered within it yet it worked very well. The characters both intregied and frustrated me at times. It took me a while to finish this one but it certainly wasn't due to the book itself!
Journal Entry 10 by ekranda at sent by post, A Bookray -- Controlled Releases on Wednesday, June 24, 2009
Released 2 yrs ago (6/24/2009 UTC) at sent by post, A Bookray -- Controlled Releases
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Have posted the book to the next person. I hope you enjoy this book as much as i did!!!
Thank you very much for sharing this book with me - i thoroughly enjoyed it!
Arrived safely today. I have two rather large bookrays to read before this but I hope to get to it soon. Thanks so much for sending this on ekranda, and for staring the ring perryfran xx
What can I say other than that I loved this book. Once I started it I fell completely into the story and found it was a really quick read. The characters were well defined and very likeable, even Melony to a certain point.
I found myself challenging my own views on abortion and respercting Dr Larch's view that 'It is all the Lord's work' and that if he didn't do it right, then someone else would end up doing it wrong. An amazing book that as many have said before me, will stay with me for quite a while. A great addition to the 1001 list and one of my alltime favourite books. Thanks again for sharing Perryfran xx
Journal Entry 13 by Danielle23 at Sunderland, Tyne and Wear United Kingdom on Monday, July 20, 2009
Released 2 yrs ago (7/20/2009 UTC) at Sunderland, Tyne and Wear United Kingdom
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Off in the post today to stubee with another bookray. I hope you enjoy them Stuart, this one is a favourite of mine xx
Journal Entry 14 by stubee from Bury, Lancashire United Kingdom on Wednesday, July 22, 2009
Thanks Danielle23 for sending this on! I hope to read it shortly but I've got another couple of rays in front of this one.
EDIT: 25th August 2009 - I started reading this novel today, intially shocked by the subject matter contained in the first few lines.
EDIT: 8th September 2009 – I absolutely loved this novel it’s my first John Irvin novel and I’ll definitely read more of his work based on this piece. Although the subject matter was very grim there is some genuine heart felt moments and in places humour, a well thought out, well written and enticing novel one that I’d recommend to anyone.
Thanks Perryfran for sharing this with me. I’ve sent a PM to davemurray101 and will get this on its way once I’ve had a response.
the state of Maine seems to create a lot of great novels - a lot of Stephen King and John Irving. A very brutal novel, captures the atmosphere of small towns and their mentality at that particular time. compared to 'A Prayer for Owen meany' it was a lot more enjoyable. thanks again to Perryfran for sharing. - Wandering B - asked to be skipped 10/10 - no response from gringuita
Journal Entry 18 by davemurray101 at A Controlled Release, a fellow bookcrosser -- Controlled Releases on Monday, October 12, 2009
Released 2 yrs ago (10/12/2009 UTC) at A Controlled Release, a fellow bookcrosser -- Controlled Releases
The book arrived safely from the other side of the world a couple of days ago. Thanks for the postcard! I'll try to get started soon, but right now I'm in the middle of another book. Meanwhile: happy Halloween!
I have been in the habit of reading The Cider House Rules in the evenings before going to bed, just like the Melony and Homer read classic novels to the kids at the orphanage. And similarly to the grand classics, the plot of this novel advances at a slow, steady rate, which leaves me a bit irritated. I don't want to get old with the characters. I want the story to develop and things to happen. Nothing much did, and so I terminated my reading at around page 200. What a solution to come to, as the major theme is abortion!
The graphic, thorough narration is admirable and captivating as it brings the characters alive, up close and personal. I also have to credit the book for its original topic and bold imagery. Apparently the problem in my case was the lack of time and patience. I would like to know what will happen in the story so I guess I'll have to watch the film version someday.
The ray has now reached its end, and I, as the last participant, thank everyone for having passed this book my way! I am now marking this as AVL and will offer it to somebody at one of our local meetings :)
1) I found a new home for the book on rabck.com and the book will soon continue its way over the Atlantic ocean.
2) A few picks from the novel:
It is up to the reader to decide whether she is for or against abortion. Irving, though bringing up both points of view, manages to put it this way: For whom did some minds insist that babies, even clearly unwanted ones, must be brought, screaming, into the world? (p.10)
And also, based on casual observations in public transport, supermarkets etc, I have to agree with the following: Loving someone as a parent can produce a cloud that conceals from one's vision what correct behaviour is. (p.112)
What a lovely surprise in my mailbox this morning. I was not expecting any books, so was very pleased to see this wish list book waiting for me. Thanks you LaPitchoune for sharing this with me. I'm looking forward to reading this.