corner corner The Good Doctor

Medium

The Good Doctor
by Damon Galgut | Literature & Fiction
Registered by Shylock of Skipton, North Yorkshire United Kingdom on Saturday, March 20, 2004
Average 7 star rating by BookCrossing Members 

status (set by tuff517): travelling


10 journalers for this copy...

Journal Entry 1 by Shylock from Skipton, North Yorkshire United Kingdom on Saturday, March 20, 2004

This book has not been rated.

2003 Booker Prize shortlist
Andre Brink likes it & that's good enough for me!
Post-apartheid South Africa. Idealist young doctor "in a world where the past is demanding restitution from the present". 


Journal Entry 2 by Shylock from Skipton, North Yorkshire United Kingdom on Monday, May 10, 2004

5 out of 10

Must confess this didn't draw me in, and the characters are not likeable. Interestingly it somehow maintains a brooding promise of disaster while appearing utterly bland. As a portrayal of post-apartheid South Africa-or one of its ex-homelands at least-it isn't very heartening: proactivity & the optimism of youth is dashed;the cynical,unambitious coasting of those previously with all the privileges is maintained and dark forces from past regimes still lurk.

Promised to goatgrrl as a trade,sending tomorrow, surface.
 


Journal Entry 3 by goatgrrl from New Westminster, British Columbia Canada on Tuesday, August 10, 2004

This book has not been rated.

A wonderful surprise in my mailbox today, received from Shylock in North Yorkshire, England. Thank you so much -- I'm so looking forward to reading this one! 


Journal Entry 4 by goatgrrl from New Westminster, British Columbia Canada on Sunday, August 15, 2004

This book has not been rated.

The Good Doctor is set in the late 1990s in a small, dilapitated hospital in an unnamed former black homeland* in South Africa. As the book begins, Frank Eloff -- a doctor who has been putting in time at the hospital for seven years -- meets Laurence Waters, a young physician dispatched to the facility to complete a mandatory one year of community medical service. There's only one catch: the hospital is all but shut down, with no more than 1 - 2 patients at any given time, the remaining staff reduced to just those left by attrition.

Eloff and Waters work with Dr. Ngome, an African woman physician, and Drs. Jorge and Claudia Santander, Cuban physicians abroad working in support of the "new" South Africa. Shylock is right (see above) -- none of these characters are particularly appealing as human beings, and nothing about their situation inspires much sympathy or respect. In a way, that's what this book is about -- a cast of characters where the lines between "good guys" and "bad guys" are completely blurred, living in an atmosphere so rife with violence, poverty and corruption that everyone has more or less given up.

The Good Doctor succeeded for me, as a novel about the challenge -- or maybe the futility -- of decolonization, and the difficulty of changing old habits of mind, politics and culture. I think it would be a good read for anyone with an interest in contemporary South Africa, or for anyone interested in tracking Booker Prize shortlisted books (this one was on the 2003 shortlist).

* During the apartheid era, there were ten self-governing homelands -- territories set aside for different black ethnic groups, four of which were granted "independence" (which was recognized only by South Africa and each other). The former homelands ceased to exist in April 1994, and were re-incorporated into South Africa and absorbed into the nine new provinces (see map at top left).
 


Journal Entry 5 by goatgrrl from New Westminster, British Columbia Canada on Monday, August 16, 2004

This book has not been rated.

INTERNATIONAL BOOKRAY

Rules of this bookray:
1. This is an international bookray -- if you join, you must be willing to ship anywhere.
2. Please journal the book when you receive it, and again when you mail it out -- that way, everyone will know the book's approximate location.
3. If you don't think you'll be able to read this book within a reasonable time of receipt, please let me know before it's sent to you by the previous reader, and I'll be happy to move your name down the list.
4. The last person on the list may do whatever he/she likes with the book -- I don't need it back.

Participants:
1. inkognitoh - West Kensington, London, UK - rec'd August 23, 04; mailed September 17, 04.
2. sweetpeeps - Lytham, Lancashire, UK - rec'd September 18, 04; mailed October 11, 04.
3. tangledthreads - Derby, England, UK - rec'd November 5, 04; mailed November 29, 04.
4. bookmanu - Cascais, Portugal - rec'd January 11, 05; mailed February 05.
5. silkina - Leipzig, Sachsen, Germany - rec'd February 25, 05; mailed May 26, 05.
6. LeapingLizzards - Fort Myers, Florida, USA - rec'd August 11, 05; sent September 05.
7. Eucalia - Sacramento, California, USA - rec'd September 25, 05; mailed October 6, 05.
8. tuff517 - McQueeney, Texas, USA - rec'd October 13, 05


Journal Entry 6 by goatgrrl from New Westminster, British Columbia Canada on Wednesday, August 18, 2004

This book has not been rated.

I mailed The Good Doctor to inkognitoh this afternoon, from Vancouver International Airport (on my way out of town). Sent it airmail, so it shouldn't take too long to reach you! 


Journal Entry 7 by inkognitoh from London , Greater London United Kingdom on Monday, August 23, 2004

This book has not been rated.

*Shortlisted for the Booker Prize 2003*

I haven't yet read any of the 2003 Booker books so am looking forward to beginning with this one. Thanks so much for sending it my way. 


Journal Entry 8 by inkognitoh from London , Greater London United Kingdom on Friday, September 17, 2004

10 out of 10

The disparate and disconnectedness of post aparthaid South Africa oozes through this quietly spun but powerful tale. I really enjoyed the slow, drawn out narrative wherein the characters all brought their flaws to the foreground and tried to make something of the new South African and find their place within it. The redundant hospital in the failed Governmental programme that is 'the homeland' territories is a superb metaphor for the broken down beauracracies of a country intent on rebuilding itself using the scraps of what was left behind.

The idealist pitted against the fatalist in the guise of the new and the old Doctor's the seemingly corrupt Hospital staff and the hangers on who came to help but only hindered the process all had a point to make. The left over sense of black versus white and the meshing and melding of the old with the new. All the concepts were contrasted and compared with precision. I empathised with the characters and found equal measures of good and bad in them all and this to me was Galgut's point - there is no right or wrong (or black and white if you will) anymore, only change and development and varying shades of grey.

I thoroughly enjoyed this book and even had one of those 'lose yourself' moments when reading it; wherein you shut the whole world out and become involved in the book in a most intimate way. This is a tale for our times and deserves a wide audience.
 


Journal Entry 9 by sweetpeeps from Cómpeta, Málaga Spain on Saturday, September 18, 2004

7 out of 10

I was delighted to receive this book from inkognitoh as part of goatgrrl's bookring. This will be the fourth shortlisted Booker Prize 2003 book that I have read. Will let you know what I think shortly!

I didn´t finish reading the book before my visit to Spain, so I brought it with me and will post it onwards from here.

I agree with Shylock that this book promised much that somehow didn´t materialise. However, I enjoyed reading The Good Doctor and found it a refreshing change of subject.

Now posting off to tangledthreads via the Spanish postal system back to UK. Enjoy!!! 


Journal Entry 10 by sweetpeeps at Posted at Nerja Post Office in Nerja, Andalucia, Spain, A Bookring -- Controlled Releases on Monday, October 11, 2004

This book has not been rated.

Released 7 yrs ago (10/11/2004 UTC) at Posted at Nerja Post Office in Nerja, Andalucia, Spain, A Bookring -- Controlled Releases

WILD RELEASE NOTES:

RELEASE NOTES:

Posted to tangledthreads in UK from Nerja, Andalucia, Spain. 


Journal Entry 11 by tangledthreads from Derby, Derbyshire United Kingdom on Friday, November 05, 2004

This book has not been rated.

Sorry for slight delay in journalling this book - I took it to work to read in my breaks, then realised I didn't have the BCID at home to journal! Anyway, I have started the book and will hopefully finish over the weekend... 


Journal Entry 12 by tangledthreads from Derby, Derbyshire United Kingdom on Friday, November 19, 2004

5 out of 10

I'm afraid, despite continued efforts, I really failed to engage with this novel. I found it quite dry and didn't care very much about what happened. Will pass on to bookmanu when I get the address.

Update November 29th: On way to bookmanu by surface mail - apologies for delay in despatch... 


Journal Entry 13 by bookmanu from Cascais, Lisboa (distrito) Portugal on Sunday, January 16, 2005

This book has not been rated.

Thanks! It was waiting for me on my return from my holiday in South Africa.I left Portugal on 15 December and arrived on 11 January. Apologies for only journalling today.

Thanks goatgrrl for starting the bookring. The 8 week period is almost up, but I promise to send it on to the next person soon.

 


Journal Entry 14 by silkina from Leipzig, Sachsen Germany on Friday, February 25, 2005

This book has not been rated.

Caught this in the mail the other day. It's third in my TBR pile right now, but don't worry, I'm a fast reader! 


Journal Entry 15 by silkina from Leipzig, Sachsen Germany on Thursday, April 28, 2005

This book has not been rated.

Goatgrrl sent me a PM reminding me that I still have the book ... I hang my head in shame and admit that I haven't found the time to read it yet. I still very much want to, though, so I'm now moving it right to the top of my TBR pile and hope that I'll get round to it within 1-2 weeks!

Thanks for being patient with me, everyone.
 


Journal Entry 16 by silkina from Leipzig, Sachsen Germany on Thursday, May 26, 2005

7 out of 10

I'm finally done reading the book and am posting it to LeapingLizzards today! I thought it was a good read, although I must admit I'm not quite sure what the hype was all about. Definitly not the most brilliant book I've ever read, and have a nagging suspicion that the book's success is mainly due to its being set in the new South Africa ... But I don't regret reading it. :) 


Journal Entry 17 by LeapingLizzards from Fort Myers, Florida USA on Thursday, August 11, 2005

8 out of 10

I really enjoyed this book, to describe it in one word, haunting.

It is one of those that I continue to think about long after I have finished reading it.
I tend to love novels that have been awarded or nominated for the Booker Prize.

Will be sending it on shortly, thanks so much for sharing. 


Journal Entry 18 by Eucalia from Snoqualmie, Washington USA on Sunday, September 25, 2005

This book has not been rated.

This book has arrived safely with me in Seattle! I'll be starting it as soon as I finish up the book I'm reading now. Thanks to LeapingLizzards for sending it to me and to goatgrrl for sharing! 


Journal Entry 19 by Eucalia at sent to bookcrosser in Mailed, Bookring -- Controlled Releases on Thursday, October 06, 2005

7 out of 10

Released 6 yrs ago (10/6/2005 UTC) at sent to bookcrosser in Mailed, Bookring -- Controlled Releases

WILD RELEASE NOTES:

RELEASE NOTES:

I finished reading this book yesterday. It was one of the books where from the moment I started reading I felt as though something big was going to happen. It started out a little slow but I kept feeling that there was going to be some terribly thought-provoking twist. In the end I was unsatisfied. It felt like the author really tried, but just couldn't deliver. Don't get me wrong, it was a good story, it just wasn't as good as I had hoped.

I put it in the mail today after work--it's on its way to tuff517 in Texas now. Thanks to goatgrrl for sharing! 


Journal Entry 20 by tuff517 from Elk Grove Village, Illinois USA on Thursday, October 13, 2005

This book has not been rated.

Received this yesterday, will start ASAP. 


Journal Entry 21 by tuff517 from Elk Grove Village, Illinois USA on Tuesday, October 25, 2005

9 out of 10

This book was easy, like a glass of cold water. Very simple, not a lot of embellishments, but great depth of emotion. I have been where Frank is; I have known people like Laurence. This was a book that was easy to slip into and hard to put down. I think there were a few loose ends, but life has a lot of loose ends, sometimes you can't tie everything up neatly. And that's okay. Looks like I'm last in this ring. I will leave it available for now and release it or trade it at a later time. Thanks so much goatgrrl! Another great book. 


Journal Entry 22 by tuff517 from Elk Grove Village, Illinois USA on Friday, April 20, 2007

This book has not been rated.

Heading to a BookMooch member. 




Are you sure you want to delete this item? It cannot be undone.