corner corner The Martian

Forum | << Based on the Book: Books to Movies | Refresh | Search

corner corner

Sort Options Toggle Stats Options


Profile Image

The Martian

I saw this yesterday, and enjoyed it - though (as my T-shirt caption says), "The book was better" {wry grin}. The book's mostly told from Mark's point of view, via his log, so we only hear from him when he's in sufficient control of himself to communicate; the film shows events unfolding, so we see the nightmarish conditions, his physical and emotional shock, etc. before we even get to *meet* the guy. The story does work quite well - wonderful cast, too, even though I'm not crazy about Matt Damon in general - but the book's version had a lot more humor as well as many more catastrophes. (The movie had to cut quite a few of the desperate situations to keep within reasonable running time, and still had lots of harrowing events.)

I do recommend the film, but I recommend the book even more. And if you like audiobooks, the audio version of this one is truly excellent!

The IMDB link:

http://www.imdb.com/---/combined

My comments here:

http://www.bookcrossing.com/---/13083460

Complete Thread

Profile Image
I saw this yesterday, and enjoyed it - though (as my T-shirt caption says), "The book was better" {wry grin}. The book's mostly told from Mark's point of view, via his log, so we only hear from him when he's in sufficient control of himself to communicate; the film shows events unfolding, so we see the nightmarish conditions, his physical and emotional shock, etc. before we even get to *meet* the guy. The story does work quite well - wonderful cast, too, even though I'm not crazy about Matt Damon in general - but the book's version had a lot more humor as well as many more catastrophes. (The movie had to cut quite a few of the desperate situations to keep within reasonable running time, and still had lots of harrowing events.)

I do recommend the film, but I recommend the book even more. And if you like audiobooks, the audio version of this one is truly excellent!

The IMDB link:

http://www.imdb.com/---/combined

My comments here:

http://www.bookcrossing.com/---/13083460/
Profile Image
Thanks. I was trying to decide if I should see it. You convinced me.
Profile Image
Thanks. I was trying to decide if I should see it. You convinced me.
ditto. Thanks for the review GoryDetails.
Profile Image
but my 24 year old daughter proclaimed it to be the absolute best movie ever.
Profile Image
I liked it and even the spousal unit thought it was pretty good. Not as good as the book, of course, but when is the movie ever as good as the book. I quite liked Damon in the role but one complaint I had is that even though he was on pretty restricted rations he never seemed to have baggy clothes or EVA suits. The suits maybe I could have understood but his clothes should have hung on him.
Profile Image
but when is the movie ever as good as the book.

The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas. In fact better by several accounts. I have seen others too, but their names escape me at this moment.
Profile Image

me too

I've seen the movie as well- Damon's done a good work
Profile Image
I agree - the book was better. Fun to see the excellent Axel Hennie play in it, though, I didn't know until I saw him there. Though, it puzzles me that they casted a Norwegian for a German part (however, I have seen Americans cast a Norwegian for a Swedish part in an American TV series...)

Are you sure you want to delete this item? It cannot be undone.